you're reading...

The River Valley iPad Debacle: Education-Based ICT Too Fast, Too Quickly?

“名校要2,800师生用iPad, 家长掀骂战” (“Fury Over Decision To Use iPads In School”).

On Tuesday, The New Paper ran a report titled “Parents Question Use Of iPad In School”; the following day, Chinese newspaper 联合晚报 published a similar article (left), titled “名校要2,800师生用iPad, 家长掀骂战” (“Fury Over Decision To Use iPads In School”). Both news pieces were relatively brief expositions on River Valley High School’s decision to get its students and teachers to use the Apple electronic hand-held device for teaching-learning purposes, and an assortment of other initiatives or activities; nonetheless, the expression of dissent is not at all surprising.

Individuals should be cognisant of the tendencies for the aforementioned publications to sensationalise anecdotal observations or reader submissions (while slight dissatisfaction might be widespread, the proposition of a “shouting match” seems grossly exaggerated, and over-dramatised). However, it is worth contemplating perspectives associated with information communications technology (ICT): why is there such an immense obsession with it; does it employment necessarily yield desirable or positive after-effects; has its benefits and advantages been overstated?

ICT In Schools: Blind Obsession Or Genuine Necessity?

In a commentary last year, I was looking at whether ICT was becoming too laissez-faire (here).

Without conclusive findings, heightened usage of ICT might not necessarily mean better-quality education for our students … [there is a] a plethora of unreliable information online, instances of plagiarism, and an assortment of distractions – for both teachers and students”.

My primary concern is that evidence in support for ICT in Singapore schools has been largely anecdotal in nature: more often than not, the Ministry of Education (MOE) uses select examples in certain institutions to illustrate how technology has “reduced learning apprehension” and “promoted creativity”. However, it has not been properly established whether there is indeed a positive correlation between the heavy use of ICT and overall academic or curricular performance (here). I remain staunchly unconvinced.

There are some considerations that should be taken into account by schools, as well as the MOE.

– Over-reliance and over-dependency, with disproportionate focuses dedicated to flashy distractions instead of concentrating on the curriculum proper.

– Disadvantageous for teachers and students who are less tech-savvy, who spend more time negotiating around applications or cosmetic amendments instead of reading substantial materials.

– Cost, and the “technological treadmill”. It may not be financially sustainable when one factors in maintenance, upgrading and telecommunications (3G, Wireless) purchases.

– Probable abuse of ICT practices by teachers (having students do additional work by themselves), under the banner of student ownership and independent learning.

– Time and effort wasted when there are experimental, technological errors, since hardware and software require years of design and fine-tuning before they are productive for active usage.

Any proposal for a technological advancement in schools should be premised upon convincing rationales, and tangible instances in a classroom setting.

The River Valley High School Debacle

Even before the newspaper articles surfaced, observers and parents – on both sides of the fence – have been discussing the implications and potential ramifications on several popular online forums. Further concerns on cyber-wellness, addiction and campus security were highlighted, but reservations on the financial costs remained the most significant. Some also lamented the poor forms of communication, but what appears apparent is the view that the school’s reputation – to a certain extent – has been sullied.

Any proposal for a technological advancement in schools – such as the incorporation of the iPads in general pedagogies – should be premised upon convincing rationales, and tangible instances in a classroom setting. It is tempting to be blinded by the lure of hype, and lose sight of actual educational methodologies. Rather than using nebulous, superfluous justifications, schools should show parents and students how the new gadget would be employed during an actual lesson; masterclasses can be coherently organised, for different subjects, for stakeholders to see how things would be actually done.

The novelty of the iPad (and ICT in general) will tempt educators to adopt them as the easy way out, under the guise of expressions like “collaborative education”, “interactive, user-based lessons”, “academic-scholastic breakthrough”, “innovative implementation of activities” et cetera. The assumption that technology automatically enhances teaching-learning experiences is extremely fallacious; so unless schools are willing to take more calculated, sound and practical approaches, we must remain wary.

About guanyinmiao

A man of knowledge lives by acting, not by thinking about acting. Carlos Castaneda.


4 thoughts on “The River Valley iPad Debacle: Education-Based ICT Too Fast, Too Quickly?

  1. It is a digital world out there. Every day billions of us use technology to learn informally. Why should formal ‘learning institutions’ ignore this trend? Isn’t it time for schools to catch up?

    Also, you have to give individual educators and entire educational systems time to navigate their own learning curves. Expecting them to have robust, complex, rich and deep understandings of how to effectively integrate tech into instruction at the beginning isn’t realistic.

    Posted by Scott McLeod (@mcleod) | February 5, 2012, 2:37 am
    • Hi Scott,

      Thanks for the comment! Yes I agree that ICT is gaining prominence for the right reasons (accessibility, collaborative learning et cetera), but in the commentary I am contending that we may be progressing in this direction too quickly without taking stock of present pedagogies or mechanisms.

      In Singapore, ICT has been gaining traction over the years (we’ve had three masterplans to chart the general direction), but my worry is that schools may be pushing too quickly without understanding the effectiveness of past efforts. As you contended, “expecting [individual educators and entire educational systems] to have robust, complex, rich and deep understandings of how to effectively integrate tech[nology] into instruction at the beginning” is not entirely constructive. Sometimes, pushing for rapid introductions of new technologies could be counter-productive.

      My High School was a “FutureSchool”, which meant that different forms of ICT were incorporated. Methodologies were really a mixed bag: some of the lessons were productive, but some teaching-learning approaches became quite pedantic and contrived (I think I should write another entry about my anecdotal experiences).

      So, yes to ICT, but at a more moderated pace (hence, the title).

      Jin Yao

      Posted by guanyinmiao | February 5, 2012, 5:35 pm
  2. Maybe we should be asking ourselves, What price are we paying for this technology? Who will benefit and who will lose from this change? What powerful idea is hidden behind this technology? Do we leave this technological change in the hands of capitalists like bill gates, steve jobs and their ilk? We are accepting technology readily and elevating them to the status of gods that demand our attention and every waking moment. Just leave your handphone at home for a day and see if you experience withdrawal symptoms.

    Posted by Gazz | May 11, 2012, 4:36 am


  1. Pingback: Pedagogies – Not Technology – Are Challenges | guanyinmiao's musings - April 11, 2016

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow guanyinmiao's musings on WordPress.com

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,296 other followers


%d bloggers like this: